A group of Canadian refugee lawyers is taking the government to court over a recent immigration ruling, calling it unfair to Nigerian asylum seekers who have streamed across the border from the United States in large numbers over the past 18 months.
The legal challenge from the Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers was prompted by the decision to designate as precedent-setting a May ruling by Canada’s Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB) rejecting the asylum claim of a Nigerian woman who fled her homeland to escape the practice of female genital mutilation.
A tribunal in the IRB’s appeals division ruled that the woman failed to qualify for asylum because she could have sought refuge in the large Nigerian cities of Ibadan or Port Harcourt, away from her rural family home.
Last month, in the wake of the appeal division ruling, the IRB said the woman’s case should be used as a “jurisprudential guide” or legal precedent in considering all future Nigerian asylum cases.
The IRB has made similar decisions in cases involving migrants from China, India and Pakistan.
The Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers said Nigerians would now likely face a higher bar to gain asylum status than they did in the past.
“It’s very problematic,” Lorne Waldman, an attorney with the association told Reuters. “It enhances the evidentiary burden on claimants from Nigeria in a way that I say is unfair.”
Canada is struggling to cope with a wave of asylum seekers, with more than 30,000 having illegally walked across the Canada-U.S. border since January 2017, according to government figures.
About 10,000 of those who crossed are Nigerian. Their acceptance rate as of June was about 33 percent, below the average of 47 percent for all those who crossed the border illegally, according to data from the IRB.
The Association of Refugee Lawyers filed a request for a judicial review of the new guideline in federal court in Toronto last month. If successful, it could seek a court order blocking the new evidentiary requirements for Nigerians, potentially covering Chinese, Indian and Pakistani asylum seekers as well.
An IRB spokeswoman said in an email that the purpose of the Nigeria guideline was to ensure “consistency and efficiency in decision-making” about refugee claims from what she described as a “major source country.”
It has already cost some claimants their chance at refugee status, according to lawyers.
Last week, an IRB tribunal member ruled against granting asylum to a Nigerian man and his family on grounds that there were safe places for them to live in Nigeria, said his lawyer Anne Castagner.
The man, who asked to be identified only as Samson out of fear for his family’s safety, said he was a prominent property developer in Nigeria when he began to be targeted by what he suspects were rival developers.
He and his family were attacked repeatedly, according to his asylum claim. They moved to another city but were pursued by the same people, he said, so they fled to the United States and then on across the border into Canada.
There was no safe flight alternative in Nigeria, he said.
“I can’t imagine having to go back to a country where our lives are not safe … They should send me back, but not the kids.”
Castagner is preparing to appeal Samson’s case but said she worries about upcoming cases.
“I don’t think the real refugees should suffer from the fact that we have a lot of Nigerians coming in,” she said.
PMB Mourns Victims Of Bomb Blasts
President Muhammadu Buhari has commiserated with families of victims of bomb blasts at a viewing centre in Mandarari, Konduga local...
Govt Ready To Pay Judiciary Staff – Kogi SSG
With the recent payment of one-month subvention to the state judiciary, Kogi State government has said that it is ready...
FG Assures ILO Of Moving Workers Out Of Poverty
The federal government yesterday assured global leaders attending this year’s International Labour Conference (ILC) holding in Geneva, Switzerland that it...
Cleric Tasks Christians On Thanksgiving
Christians across the world have been charged to imbibe the spirit of thanksgiving, supplication and adoration to God as a...
Police Deny Discovery Of Arms In Adamawa Poly Mosque
Adamawa State Police Command, have denied reports that arms was allegedly discovered in the Mosque inside the State Polytechnic Yola...
US-China Trade War Plunges Huawei Smartphone Sales By 40%
Huawei founder Ren Zhengfei has said international sales of the Chinese telecoms giant’s handsets have sunk 40% in the past...
Former Egyptian President Morsi Dies In Court
Egypt’s deposed President,Mohamed Morsi has died following a session in court, a state-run television station and newspaper reported yesterday. Morsi,...
POLITICS18 hours ago
APC Kicks As Bauchi Govt Suspends Inauguration Of 9th Assembly
COVER STORIES7 hours ago
Fear Grips Lawmakers As FG Begins Probe Of Constituency Projects
NEWS22 hours ago
1 Killed, 6 Vehicles Destroyed As Kona, Fulani Clash.
NEWS15 hours ago
Taraba Govt Deny Imposing Curfew On Jalingo.
AFRICA16 hours ago
Former Egyptian President Morsi Dies In Court During Sitting
NEWS21 hours ago
Windstorm Destroys Over 1000 Houses In Zamfara LGA
FOOTBALL24 hours ago
PSG Consider Neymar Sale As Club Chairman Warns To Players
NEWS3 hours ago
EDHA Inaugurated, Okiye Emerges Speaker